top of page

Steroid Injections vs hyaluronic acid mixed with Steroid (Cingal®) for Osteoarthritis: Which Is Better for Joint Pain?

Nov 3
5 min read

Writer: Dominic Moon

DCM Physiotherapy – Bedale, North Yorkshire

5 min read

At DCM Physiotherapy, we regularly see patients struggling with joint pain, stiffness, and reduced mobility caused by osteoarthritis or degenerative meniscus. A common question is whether a traditional corticosteroid injection is the best option, or whether newer treatments such as CINGAL may offer longer-lasting relief.

While both treatments can help manage osteoarthritis symptoms, they work in slightly different ways.

Traditional steroid injections focus on reducing inflammation and providing short-term pain relief. CINGAL combines a corticosteroid with hyaluronic acid (HA), aiming to provide both rapid pain relief and longer-lasting joint lubrication.

Understanding the differences can help you make a more informed decision about managing your joint pain.


What Is Osteoarthritis (OA)?

Osteoarthritis is a common joint condition that affects the cartilage, joint fluid, bone, and surrounding tissues.

It commonly affects the:

  • Knees

  • Hips

  • Hands and fingers

  • Spine

Symptoms often include:

  • Pain during walking or exercise

  • Joint stiffness, particularly after resting

  • Swelling and inflammation

  • Reduced movement and flexibility

  • Difficulty with everyday activities

Although osteoarthritis cannot currently be cured, physiotherapy, strengthening exercises, lifestyle changes, and selected injection treatments can help manage symptoms.


How Steroid Injections Work for Osteoarthritis and Degenerative Meniscus

Corticosteroid injections have been widely used for many years to manage painful osteoarthritis.

They work by reducing inflammation within the joint, helping to decrease pain and swelling.

Steroid injections can be effective for:

  • Painful flare-ups of osteoarthritis

  • Significant joint inflammation

  • Swelling that limits movement

  • Short-term pain relief to allow rehabilitation

Many patients notice improvement within a few days, although the response varies.

How Long Does a Steroid Injection Last?

Steroid injections generally provide short-term relief, often lasting several weeks, although some patients experience benefits for a few months.

However, they do not replace lost joint lubrication or reverse cartilage damage.

Repeated injections also need careful consideration, as frequent corticosteroid use may negatively affect joint tissues.

Key point: Steroid injections can be useful for managing painful flare-ups, but they are not a long-term solution to osteoarthritis.


What Is Cingal®

CINGAL is a single injection that combines two treatments:

  1. Corticosteroid (triamcinolone hexacetonide): Helps reduce inflammation and provide rapid pain relief.

  2. Hyaluronic acid (HA): Helps lubricate and cushion the joint, potentially improving comfort during movement.

Hyaluronic acid is naturally found within healthy joint fluid and plays an important role in allowing joints to move smoothly.

In osteoarthritis, the joint environment changes, and the natural lubricating properties of the joint fluid may become less effective.

CINGAL aims to address both inflammation and lubrication within one injection.

The treatment is primarily used for symptomatic knee osteoarthritis.


How CINGAL Works for Joint Pain

CINGAL offers two potential benefits.


1. Fast Pain Relief from the Steroid

The corticosteroid component helps settle inflammation within the joint.

This may provide:

  • Reduced pain

  • Less swelling

  • Improved movement

  • Greater comfort during everyday activities

Some patients experience improvement within the first few days.

2. Longer-Lasting Relief from Hyaluronic Acid

The hyaluronic acid component helps improve the lubricating and cushioning properties of the joint fluid.

This may help:

  • Reduce discomfort during movement

  • Improve joint function

  • Reduce stiffness

  • Provide longer-lasting symptom relief

Clinical studies have demonstrated improvements in knee osteoarthritis symptoms lasting up to six months and in some patients up to a year.

According to Joint Pain Freedom, clinical research into CINGAL has reported encouraging treatment responses at both one week and six months.


Steroid Injection vs CINGAL: What's the Difference?


Steroid injection

CINGAL injection

Main ingredients

Corticosteroid

Corticosteroid + HA

Reduces inflammation

Yes

Yes

Improves joint lubrication

No

Aims to

Onset of relief

Usually within days

Usually within days

Duration of benefit

Often weeks

6 months+

Main purpose

Short-term symptom relief

Rapid and potentially longer-lasting relief

Important: Cingal® may offer longer-lasting symptom relief for some patients, but it is not guaranteed to outperform a standard steroid injection for everyone. Neither treatment has been proven to regenerate damaged cartilage or cure osteoarthritis.


Are There Any Risks or Side Effects?

Both steroid and CINGAL injections are generally well tolerated, but they are not suitable for everyone.

Possible side effects include:

  • Temporary pain or swelling after the injection

  • Bruising around the injection site

  • A temporary increase in blood sugar, particularly in people with diabetes

  • Allergic reactions

  • A small risk of joint infection

Repeated steroid injections also require caution because of potential effects on cartilage and surrounding tissues.

If you develop a hot, very swollen joint, fever, or feel significantly unwell following an injection, seek urgent medical assessment.

A qualified clinician should review your medical history, medications, and suitability before recommending either treatment.


What Does Current Research Suggest?

Research supports corticosteroid injections as an option for short-term pain relief in knee osteoarthritis.

CINGAL has also been investigated in randomised controlled trials, with studies demonstrating improvements in pain and function following treatment.

The combination of corticosteroid and hyaluronic acid is designed to provide early symptom relief alongside the potentially longer-lasting effects of HA.


Why Physiotherapy Is Still Important

Whether you choose a steroid injection or CINGAL, physiotherapy remains an important part of managing osteoarthritis.

An injection may reduce pain, but it does not automatically improve muscle strength, joint control, or physical fitness.

At DCM Physiotherapy, we focus on:

  • Strengthening the muscles supporting the affected joint

  • Improving joint mobility and flexibility

  • Gradually increasing activity and exercise tolerance

  • Improving balance and movement control

  • Helping patients return to walking, sport, and everyday activities

Reducing pain through an injection may create an opportunity to exercise more comfortably.

Think of injections as tools to help manage symptoms, rather than replacements for rehabilitation.


Can Injections Delay Joint Replacement Surgery?

For some patients, injections may help control symptoms sufficiently to continue managing osteoarthritis without immediate surgery.

The aim is to improve pain, movement, and quality of life while exploring appropriate non-surgical management options.

Final Takeaway

Steroid injections and CINGAL can both play a role in managing osteoarthritis, but there are important differences.

  • Steroid injections can provide relatively quick, short-term relief from inflammation and pain.

  • CINGAL combines a steroid with hyaluronic acid, aiming to provide rapid relief alongside longer-lasting symptom improvement.

  • Neither treatment cures osteoarthritis or reverses existing cartilage damage.

  • Physiotherapy and strengthening exercises remain essential for improving joint function and maintaining activity.

For some patients, a standard steroid injection may be sufficient. For others, particularly those with persistent knee osteoarthritis symptoms, CINGAL may be an option worth considering.

The best treatment depends on your symptoms, medical history, activity levels, and individual goals.


When to See a Physiotherapist

If you're based in Bedale, North Yorkshire, or the surrounding Yorkshire Dales, consider booking an appointment if:

  • Knee or hip pain is affecting your walking

  • Joint stiffness is limiting everyday activities

  • Osteoarthritis symptoms are becoming more frequent

  • Previous injections have provided only temporary relief

  • You want advice on exercise, rehabilitation, or injection treatment options

At DCM Physiotherapy, we can assess your joint symptoms, help you understand your treatment options, inject your knee and develop a rehabilitation programme to keep you moving.

The goal isn't simply to reduce pain — it's to help you stay active, strong, and confident in your joints for as long as possible.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page